Using your own router for home broadband
By Phil Wilkinson-Jones | Friday, September 25th 2020
Ok, so you're thinking about whether to replace the free router provided by your broadband provider. There's a lot to think about, right? Will the one you buy be compatible with your broadband connection? What should you be looking for in a router anyway? And is it all worth it? Woah! Slow down! Let us help.
We're here to take you through all those questions and more, with the aim of helping you work out whether you should stick with the router you've already got or twist and go for a bit of third-party tech.
Can I use my own router with my broadband?
Most broadband providers will allow you to use a third party router instead of the free one provided to you as part of your broadband deal. But they don't tend to recommend it and some warn that it will make it more difficult for them to help if you encounter a fault.
If you do decide to get your own router, you'll have to configure it to work with your broadband and in some cases you'll still need to use your provider's supplied router as a modem. Below is what we've been able to find out about setting up your own router with each of the UK's major broadband providers. If you're serious about this and need more details, contact your provider directly or head over to their community pages for help.
BT says it doesn't recommend using a third party router but says that if you do, you need to use the login email@example.com with the password 'bt' when setting up the PPPoE networking protocol.
Virgin says that in order to use your own router with its broadband, you'll need to use its Hub 3 as a modem. Enter 192.168.0.1 into your browser and enter the password printed on the bottom of your Hub 3 when prompted. Then select modem mode>enable modem mode>apply changes. The process is much the same if you have an older Virgin Super Hub.
You can use a third party router as long as it's compatible with Sky's MER/Option 61 connection protocol. Sky won't tell you your VDSL username and password (a security feature built into the supplied Netgear router) but there are ways of finding it out, including using software such as Wireshark to inspect your network traffic.
TalkTalk lists all of the connection setting you'll need to enter on its community website. They're different for fibre and non-fibre broadband connections so make sure you're using the right set.
Routers supporting Ethernet WAN can be used with EE's fibre broadband. The provider says to get in touch if you need your EE router password or log in details.
Plusnet has a whole help page on its website dedicated to helping you set up a third party router to use with its broadband.
SSE advises customers to get in touch and it will help you set up your own router, but warns that it will then be difficult to help you at a later date if there's a fault.
John Lewis Broadband
John Lewis 'strongly recommends' you use the router it sends you. But you can if you want, as long as its supports VDSL2 and you're happy not to get router help from the John Lewis team.
Some Hyperoptic customers on gigabit broadband deals have said a third party router is needed to access the very top speeds. Hyperoptic itself says ADSL routers are not compatible and that you won't be able to use your Hyperoptic phone line with the Hyperoptic router. Using the supplied router as a modem and your own purely as a router does allow use of the phone line, however.
Shell Energy Broadband
Shell recommends you use the supplied router, but will give you the router credentials you need to start using another if you call up and ask for them.
Vodafone says any non-Vodafone router you use with its broadband has to be one approved by Openreach. The password for the interface is 'Vodafone' and to get your DSL username and password, chat to Voda online.
Post Office Broadband
As far as we can tell, you can use a third party router with Post Office Broadband's non-fibre ADSL broadband but not with any of its fibre packages.
It is possible to use your own router with Now Broadband. But like its parent company Sky, Now doesn't make it easy. Now Broadband will not tell you any of the passwords you need, but users on the Now Broadband community pages are usually happy to help.
Direct Save Broadband
There's nothing on Direct Save's website about using your own router with its broadband. In our experience that suggests they may not be in favour of it, but you'd have to call up and speak to them to find out.
Something that all providers agree on is that you can't use a free router from one provider with broadband from another. The routers they provide are locked to that particular provider.
The benefits of using your own router
Ok, so we've established that there's a bit of set-up to do if you're to use your own router rather than one sent to you by your broadband provider. So is it worth it? These are reasons why you might want to do it.
- Control over your network – Routers from ISPs are configured automatically and providers warn customers not to mess with the settings. For most users, this isn't a problem but if you have an IT background or are into your tech, there may be certain things you want to do with your network. Using your own router will facilitate this
- Improved network security – If you're unhappy with your ISP-supplied router's security features then getting your own is your only option. You'll be able to download security updates quicker, install advanced firewalls and more
- Faster wifi – The free routers sent out by providers are rarely top-of-the-range, so can't always give you the fastest wireless speeds possible. Investing in a mid-range third-party router could help you see faster wifi at home
- Access to open source software – There is no way a broadband provider is going to let you use open source software with its router. If experimenting with firmware options or router-based VPN clients is your kind of thing, you know what to do
- QoS – Quality of Service is a traffic management features let you prioritise particular devices, so you can ensure you always have enough bandwidth to play your game or make that video call, even if the whole family is online at the same time
- Improved range – While most routers supplied by providers do their job adequately, if you have the spare dough, you can buy routers with substantially more range. These tend not to be cheap, however
What are the downsides to using your own router?
The most obvious downside to buying your own router is the cost. The one you got from your broadband provider was free, right? Well, the cost argument really depends on how much you want the extra features. If having more control over your network really means a lot to you, then the initial outlay on a quality router is going to seem more than worth it over the years.
The other thing that puts people off is the complexity. If you don't like the idea of getting into the nitty gritty of network configurations, we totally understand. It's not for everyone. That said, a number of store-bought routers are relatively easy to install and will give you noticeable results without much tinkering.
What features should I look for when buying a router?
There is a lot of choice out there, but these are some of the things to look for when choosing which router is right for you.
- Wireless router standards – The wifi standard that your router uses has a huge bearing on how fast a connection you're going to get on your wireless devices. 802.11ac, for example, isn't the very latest standard but it is fast and widely supported, so would be a good bet
- Gigabit ethernet – If you're investing in a router, it makes sense for it to be futureproof – and that means ready for gigabit broadband. Having gigabit support also helps to get the best possible speeds from your existing connections
- Dual band – Dual band routers support both the 2.4Ghz and 5Ghz frequencies. This helps cut out interference from other nearby wifi networks. As 5Ghz is often used for faster connections but has a shorter range, using both frequencies means you can link different devices to the one that's most suitable
- USB sockets – It's always good to have the option of a wired connection for things like printers and external hard drives, so a couple of spare USB sockets is certainly something to look for
- Parental controls – Some ISP's routers include parental controls and there are, of course, apps you can use to limit what your children are doing online. But third-party routers give you far more control, and applying restrictions directly at the router tends to be more effective
What are the best third party routers?
There are a lot of routers out there, each with different features and sitting at various price brackets. Here are a few it may be worth considering, but this is by no means an exhaustive list so it's vital you do your own research.
- D-Link EXO AC2600 – This router doesn't include a modem so would be ideal to link with a Virgin router used as a modem. It offers fast wireless speeds using 802.11ac and a good range of parental control features
- Tenda AC10U – More of a budget offering, the Tenda can't match top-of-the-range routers for performance but would be an upgrade on most free ISP routers, plus it offers easy set-up and an app to manage the router from your phone
- AVM Fritz!Box 7590 – A bit more expensive than the others we've mentioned so far, this router is great for techies who want to get involved in every level of managing their wireless network. You can even pair it with the Fritz!Repeater 3000 to form a mesh network in your home
- Linksys EA9500 – Again, this is not a cheap router. But it does have eight aerials and offers incredible wireless speeds, as well as eight ethernet ports and twin USB 3 ports
- Asus DSL-AC68U – This Asus router comes with a built-in ADSL modem so if you're on an ADSL connection, it is going to give you as good a wireless network as you're likely to get. It has four ethernet ports and a USB 3 socket
What are the best free routers from broadband providers?
Free routers from broadband providers do have their merits. After all, the vast majority of broadband users wouldn't be able to get online as easily as they do if these routers were all that bad, would they? Here are the ones we think are the best.
- TalkTalk Wi-Fi Hub – There's very few features to talk of here. No USB port, no VPN support, not much in the way of parental controls. But it is very fast and it's quite pretty, which will be the two most important things for a lot of people. If you're an existing TalkTalk customer and don't have a Wi-Fi Hub, you can upgrade for £30
- BT Smart Hub/Smart Hub X – The specs on BT's router offering are pretty good. It's speed almost matches up to TalkTalk, it's dual band, and unlike most ISP routers it has a USB port
- Virgin Media Hub 3 – Virgin's router is a few years old now and if you're on a 200Mbps package or more then you may find that your wireless speeds are a long way off what you can get over a wired connection. That said, it's fairly reliable and will easily give you wifi speeds over 100Mbps which is more than enough for most people
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to buy a separate modem if using my own router?
Some routers do require the use of a separate modem while others have one built-in. This is something you'll need to check when buying. It's worth remembering that some ISP routers can be used as a modem and some even insist on you doing this.
Should I build my own router?
There are a lot of technical considerations, but there is also plenty of help available online and none of the routers on the market are quite what you're looking for, it is certainly an option if you're technically-minded.
Is it better to have your own router?
There are a number of things to consider, including cost, how much control you want over your wireless network and how fast you want your wifi to be. Having your own router rather than the one you got free from a provider will almost always give you a better network, but you need to balance this with the cost and effort you'll need to put in. And remember: you'll only get limited help from your provider if you encounter problems with a router they didn't give you.